• Banner 1
  • Banner 2
  • Banner 3

Taste Of Amish: Authentic Fresh Sandwiches & Friendly Service in Paintsville, KY

Taste Of Amish in Paintsville, KY, offers a warm, bustling bakery experience known for its fresh, flavorful sandwiches and homemade cookies. Their signature Amish Deluxe sandwich features tender bread and fresh ingredients that melt in your mouth, showcasing authentic, hearty flavors. Customers praise the friendly, knowledgeable staff and the inviting atmosphere, where quality and care meet. Alongside delicious subs, they offer a variety of soups and seasonal items, emphasizing fresh, non-processed foods. Taste Of Amish perfectly balances tradition and taste, making every visit a satisfying and memorable meal experience. Highly recommended for those craving genuine, wholesome comfort food.

Taste Of Amish at a glance

  • Address 950 Broadway St, Paintsville, KY 41240, United States
  • Phone +1 606-264-5926
  • Restaurant type Sandwich shop .
  • Popular for Lunch , Dinner , Solo dining .

Photos & Gallery

Taste Of Amish: Reviews & Ratings

C Susie
5

Enter the bakery from Broadway Street. It was full of customers. The ham sandwich was perfect. The staff was also friendly and kind. Highly recommend!

Goron Gaming
5

"Every time I visit this restaurant, it's a delightful experience! The food is absolutely incredible – their sandwiches are hands down the best I've ever had. The staff are friendly and efficient, making the whole experience even more enjoyable. I would highly recommend this place to anyone looking for a delicious and satisfying meal

Emily Gibson
5

Always busy, always fresh, always pleasant. They have a tight space, but they make a great sub or sandwich and the cookies are yum!! Oh, and they almost always have seasonal, fresh items.

Ben Welch
5

Great place to eat. They have a great variety of soups and sandwiches on the menu and very reasonable prices. I ordered the Philly Steak sandwich and it was awesome. Will definitely return. Also a decent selection of fresh, non processed food items on the shelves you can purchase.

Shelly H
5

Amazing! Incredibly friendly and hard working people with lots of knowledge and suggestions. The amish deluxe is so delicious. The bread melts in your mouth but holds together nicely. Really fresh ingredients. Definitely will return for a hot sandwich and other goodies from the shelf.

Colt Vance
5

Very nice tasty food! Also great assortment of sweets.

RC in KY
4

A Taste of Amish 950 Broadway St., Paintsville, KY Hidden at the back of the plaza, A Taste of Amish is a must-visit spot for anyone craving delicious, high-quality food! My father and I stopped by and tried the Philly Cheese Steak and the Chicken Parm Sub —both were absolutely incredible! The portions are generous, the flavors are outstanding, and the prices are very reasonable considering the quality. They offer daily specials to keep things interesting, and you can even pick up fresh deli meats and cheeses while you’re there. Perfect for a quick lunch or taking something delicious home for dinner! Keep in mind, seating is limited, so this is mainly a carry-out restaurant . Also, it’s tucked away in the back of the plaza and not very visible from the road , so make sure to look for it—it’s a true hidden gem. #ATasteOfAmish #PhillyCheeseSteakLovers #LocalEats #PaintsvilleKYFoodie #HiddenGemKY #SupportLocalBusinesses #CarryOutDelights #DailySpecials #AmishGoodness Don’t let the tucked-away location fool you—this is one spot you don’t want to miss!

Location

  • Taste Of Amish
    Taste Of Amish
    950 Broadway St, Paintsville, KY 41240, United States Hotline: +1 606-264-5926

Located on Broadway Street in Paintsville, Kentucky, Taste Of Amish offers a genuine slice of Amish culinary tradition. This cozy bakery and eatery is a bustling hub, inviting a steady flow of customers drawn to its fresh, hearty fare. The star of the menu is undoubtedly their sandwiches — from the classic ham to the robust Philly Steak, each bite delivers a perfect balance of quality ingredients and homemade bread that melts in your mouth while staying firm.

What sets Taste Of Amish apart is not just the food but the warmth of its staff, whose friendly and knowledgeable service elevates every visit. The Amish Deluxe sandwich, highly praised by patrons, showcases the careful harmony of freshness and simplicity intrinsic to Amish cooking. Alongside sandwiches, the menu features a variety of soups and seasonal items, all made with unprocessed, wholesome ingredients that reflect genuine care and tradition.

Beyond the prepared meals, the shop also stocks a range of fresh goods, inviting customers to take home authentic Amish flavors. The inviting atmosphere, combined with reasonable prices and consistently delicious offerings, makes Taste Of Amish a destination worth returning to. Whether you’re grabbing a quick sub or savoring a warm sandwich and a cookie, the experience feels authentically homemade and satisfyingly fresh every time.

Business Information

  • Accessibility
    • Wheelchair-accessible car park
    • Wheelchair-accessible entrance
    • Wheelchair-accessible seating
    • Wheelchair-accessible toilet
  • Service options
    • Takeaway
    • Dine-in
    • Delivery
  • Payments
    • Credit cards
    • Debit cards
    • Credit cards